How AI Search Is Changing Brand Visibility and Advertising

Play Video

This week, Voices of Search welcomed back Phillip Thune, CEO of Adthena, the AI search intelligence platform that tracks what brands and their competitors do across Google and ChatGPT. The conversation made the case that paid and organic search can no longer be run as separate disciplines, and Phillip’s research on both platforms shows why.

The conversation also walked through the growth of AI Overviews, ads appearing inside those answers, how ChatGPT ads behave differently from anything built for Google, and what search teams should be testing before 2027.

Key Takeaways From This Episode:

  • AI Overviews now appear on 48% of monitored US commercial terms, up from about 15% six months earlier
  • Ads inside AI Overviews grew from about 0.03% to over 2% of monitored searches, and that share is expected to keep rising
  • A click drop on a term now has two possible causes, an AI Overview or a competitor outbidding you, and each calls for a different response
  • ChatGPT ads can misfire in ways Google search teams do not expect, from unrelated placements to sharp click drops after a bid change
  • Paid and organic visibility now inform each other across a growing number of AI surfaces
  • Brands that have not tested ChatGPT ads yet risk falling behind in the first holiday season where they matter

Google Can Afford to Put an AI Answer Above Its Own Ads

Adthena checks Google more than 20 million times a day and ChatGPT at least a million, then pairs that with client ad account data to estimate clicks and CPCs for brands that are not clients. That is how Phillip can say AI Overviews now appear on 48% of the several million commercial terms Adthena monitors in the US, up from roughly 15% earlier in 2026, with ads usually sitting below them.

Tyson asked why Google would risk its ad revenue this way. The revenue engine has flipped, according to Phillip. Growth used to come from rising CPCs and now comes from more clicks across far more pages, since people ask Google more questions than they used to.

“They’re definitely getting fewer ad clicks per page because AI overviews are answering people’s questions, and they don’t even see the ads. But there are so many more pages,” Phillip said.

AI Overviews Turned a Click Drop Into a Two-Cause Problem

When an AI Overview sits above a result, click-through rate falls and CPC tends to rise a little. That pattern used to point to a single culprit. Now there are two to separate:

  • Competitor effect: Rivals are pouring more money into the auction, which a brand can answer by fighting back or moving to a less competitive category
  • AI Overview effect: An overview shows up for the term more often than not, and there is not much a brand can do about it

“Historically, if clicks went down and CPCs went up on a particular search term, there was only one reason. Today, it could be two reasons,” Phillip said.

Ads Are Moving Inside the Answer

For most of this year, ads inside AI Overviews sat around 0.03% of monitored searches, which Phillip read as Google testing. That share is now over 2%. Performance Max and AI Max have been the way in, and broad match is starting to qualify, so he expects it to keep climbing. Gemini carries no ads yet, and he expects that to change in 2027.

ChatGPT Ads Do Not Follow the Google Playbook

ChatGPT launched ads as a test in February and already runs at over a billion dollars annually with more than 100,000 advertisers. Capabilities arrive nearly every week, but advertisers still get no volume data and no view into which prompts trigger an ad.

That shows up in how bids behave. One client lowered its max CPC from $10 to $8 and expected roughly 20% fewer clicks, as it would on Google. Click-through rate fell far more than that, which Phillip read as ChatGPT showing the ad against less qualified prompts. He cautioned against over-indexing on one example, but Adthena could see the prompt mix change.

“They are very much flying a plane while they’re still building it,” Phillip said.

Relevance Is Looser, and Rivals Can Land in Your Comparison Prompts

Adthena collects data as a logged-out user so personalization does not skew what it sees. Across its observations, relevance breaks down like this:

  • Bang on: Around 25% of ads match the prompt directly, such as a Nike or Adidas ad after a sneaker search
  • Related: Another 50 to 60% are close, such as a sporting goods retailer for a running shoes prompt
  • Unrelated: Roughly 10 to 12% have nothing to do with the prompt

Part of the reason is coverage, since 100,000 advertisers cannot fill every category. The bigger surprise is comparison prompts. When someone asks ChatGPT about brand X versus brand Y, an ad for a third company appears 80 to 90% of the time, which is why some of the largest spenders buy the slot too.

“You asked about X versus Y, they show you an ad for Z,” Phillip said.

Paid and Organic Are Now Working the Same Problem

Tyson asked whether these shifts should push paid and organic teams together or apart. Phillip said together. A brand may show up regularly in ChatGPT and not at all in Claude, Gemini or AI Mode, so teams need to know where they are strong organically and where paid has to fill in. A strong organic recommendation can even change the math, since the ChatGPT ad sits below the answer. Some big spenders dominate the answer and buy the ad too, while others decide the answer is enough.

“If you don’t have a holistic view of what’s going on across these surfaces, you’re not going to be able to optimize as well as you could,” Phillip said.

Leaning In Beats Waiting for Certainty

Phillip admitted his answer on the biggest mistake brands make was self-serving. Brands are not leaning in. Over half of Adthena’s 400-plus clients have not tried ChatGPT ads, even though this is the first holiday season with them, widespread AI Overviews and ads in AI Mode. Tyson compared skipping it to skipping the preseason. A test of $10,000 to $50,000 is enough, and Adthena’s data has helped teams win that budget by showing a CFO that their top competitors are already there.

“Get in there. You don’t need to get in there with $200,000,” Phillip said.

Even Brand Searches Are Giving Way to AI Answers

Phillip’s most interesting recent finding is AI Overviews on brand searches. He had expected brand results to be the last part of Google to change, with text ads on top and the traditional layout intact. AI Overviews are now appearing there on a fairly consistent basis, and every category he tracks is moving in the same direction.

“Google is going to do what makes people happy because they don’t want to lose the people,” Phillip said.

Paid and Organic Teams Now Share One Results Page

AI Overviews now sit above the results on nearly half of monitored commercial searches, ads are starting to appear inside them, and ChatGPT has opened a second ad platform that follows its own rules. A drop in clicks can come from the answer box or from a competitor, and telling which takes paid and organic data read side by side.

Teams that test ChatGPT ads now, track who gets recommended across AI surfaces and share what they learn between paid and organic will know what to fix when the numbers move. 

Paid and organic search now answer to the same results, and the teams that work from one shared view of them will be the ones that keep winning clicks.

Voices of Search is a daily SEO and content marketing podcast hosted by Jordan Koene and Tyson Stockton. The show delivers actionable strategies and data-driven insights to help marketers navigate the ever-evolving world of search engine optimization and content marketing. New episodes air weekly, covering everything from technical SEO to AI discovery, featuring industry leaders and practitioners sharing real-world frameworks and proven tactics.

Subscribe to Voices of Search on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform. Follow Previsible on LinkedIn for updates and subscribe to the VOS YouTube channel for video episodes and clips.

Your buyers are already asking AI who to trust. Let's make sure they find you.

blog-cta

Curiosity opens doors. Hard work gets through. Adaptability finds the right door.